Podcasts

An employee secretly records a meeting at work and faces the legal implications

Under RICA, a person may lawfully record a conversation they are part of without the other participants’ consent. But that doesn’t mean there can be no workplace consequences. This episode explores the Labour Court’s October 2026 judgment in AkzoNobel SA (Pty) Ltd v NUMSA obo Mkhize and Others, examining the distinction between lawful recording and workplace misconduct, why the Court set aside the arbitration award, and the practical lessons for employers.

 

– Ross Simon (Associate, BCom (Law) LLB, Post Graduate Diploma in Labour Law Practice),
WP Moolman (Partner: Equity, LLB), Ulrich Stander (Managing Partner & Director, BA LLB LLM IRDP)

A subordinate was sworn at and physically stopped from walking away

In this case dismissal was fair. In Lebi v Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration and Others, the Labour Court held that an operations manager who swore at a subordinate and physically turned her back by her shoulders as she walked away was fairly dismissed for abusive language and assault. No injury or intent to harm is needed for assault, and provocation, the lack of a zero-tolerance policy and inconsistency arguments all failed because the misconduct was serious.

 

– Ross Simon (Associate, BCom (Law) LLB, Post Graduate Diploma in Labour Law Practice),
WP Moolman (Partner: Equity, LLB), Ulrich Stander (Managing Partner & Director, BA LLB LLM IRDP)

Can a zero-tolerance assault policy still justify dismissal when Two employees fight, then forgive each other?

Yes, a zero-tolerance assault policy does not automatically justify dismissal. In DSV Solutions v NUM obo Palmer and Others, the Labour Court upheld reinstatement after finding dismissal too harsh, despite proven misconduct. The employee’s long service, the isolated nature of the incident, the absence of injury and the colleagues’ subsequent reconciliation all informed the fairness of the sanction.

 

– Ross Simon (Associate, BCom (Law) LLB, Post Graduate Diploma in Labour Law Practice),
WP Moolman (Partner: Equity, LLB), Ulrich Stander (Managing Partner & Director, BA LLB LLM IRDP)

Is dismissal an appropriate sanction when an employee calls a manager a “white racist”

In this episode we unpack the Labour Appeal Court’s decision in Qomoyi v Namaqua Wines, handed down in April 2026. The case highlights why context, history, the objective test, the employer’s onus, and proportionality of sanction matter when dealing with race-related misconduct in the workplace.

A valuable reminder for employers: inflammatory words cannot be assessed in isolation — context is critical.

 

– Ross Simon (Associate, BCom (Law) LLB, Post Graduate Diploma in Labour Law Practice),
WP Moolman (Partner: Equity, LLB), Ulrich Stander (Managing Partner & Director, BA LLB LLM IRDP)

Dismissed an employee as they had been arrested for drunk driving while off duty

Dismissal for off-duty drunk driving is not automatically justified. In IMATU obo Sauls v City of Cape Town & Others, the Labour Court found the dismissal unfair because the employer could not prove a clear link between the employee’s off-duty conduct and his work. Employers must consider the nature of the employee’s job, the impact on the workplace, consistency in disciplinary action, and mitigating factors before deciding on dismissal.

 

– Ross Simon (Associate, BCom (Law) LLB, Post Graduate Diploma in Labour Law Practice),
WP Moolman (Partner: Equity, LLB), Ulrich Stander (Managing Partner & Director, BA LLB LLM IRDP)

When singing and dancing at lunch break leads to dismissal

A lunchtime gathering of employees singing, dancing, and carrying placards led to their dismissal for alleged illegal picketing. This Labour Court judgment in the case AMCU obo Sebalela Agreement and 9 Others v Fraser Alexander (Pty) Ltd. highlights the importance of evidence, fair procedure, and accurately distinguishing workplace misconduct from innocent conduct before imposing the ultimate sanction of dismissal.
– Ross Simon (Associate, BCom (Law) LLB, Post Graduate Diploma in Labour Law Practice),
WP Moolman (Partner: Equity, LLB), Ulrich Stander (Managing Partner & Director, BA LLB LLM IRDP)

No results found.